What we learned from SMB Tools YC applications
Aggregate insights from real applications roasted on YC Roaster — the patterns YC partners look for, and the weaknesses that come up over and over.
Compare these aggregate benchmarks with your cofounder without sharing your own application.
YC Roaster AI scores, not YC admissions odds.
Apps analyzed
11
Average score
3.52 /5
Updated
Oct 9, 2026
Score breakdown — SMB Tools average
Biggest weaknesses
Where SMB Tools applications consistently fall short.
- 1. Early Traction2.77/5
- 2. GTM3.22/5
- 3. Monetization3.23/5
Strongest dimensions
Where SMB Tools applications tend to do well.
- 1. App Completeness4.34/5
- 2. Market3.78/5
- 3. Team Quality3.69/5
Score distribution
What our AI judge actually said
Anonymized critique from real SMB Tools applications (shared with founder consent).
“Zero revenue after six months despite proving 4x ROI suggests pricing resistance or sales execution gaps.”
6.8/10·Strong founder who validated real pain, but must convert free pilots to paid customers within 60 days.
“If every FDD needs heavy lawyer review and state-by-state hand-holding, you've built an expensive consulting firm with a chatbot, not a scalable platform.”
7.8/10·Exceptional team taking a huge swing at real pain, but the core product hasn't shipped and regulatory complexity could kill the unit economics.
“Zero revenue and no proof anyone changed a decision because of this, so it might just be a ChatGPT wrapper founders won't pay for.”
6.5/10·Capable builder who shipped fast, but needs paying customers and decision outcome proof in 60 days to cross the threshold.
“Solo founder trying to scale software and physical ops with no co-founder, no proof AI automation works beyond five accounts.”
8.6/10·Real traction and founder-market fit, but needs to prove one person can build the moat before competition copies the playbook.
“Your entire business depends on unproven AI delivering legally compliant documents without catastrophic liability, and all revenue is 12+ months out.”
8.4/10·Exceptional founder-market fit and bold vision, but success hinges on AI quality and franchisees actually opening.
“The indie DTC wedge may be too small for venture scale, you need a path beyond $19/mo solos or risk building a nice $10M lifestyle business.”
7.4/10·Real velocity, real customers, real pain, but prove the next 50 come faster than the first 2 and the wedge expands up-market.
See where your SMB Tools app stacks up
Get a YC-partner-style scorecard on your application in 72 hours. Free.
Get your free roast →